Charitable remainder trusts: turn one big gain into years of income
The short answer
A charitable remainder trust lets you contribute a highly appreciated asset — stock, real estate, a business interest — to an irrevocable trust, which then sells it without triggering immediate capital gains tax at the trust level. You (or another beneficiary) draw an income stream from the trust for a term of years or life, take a partial charitable deduction upfront based on the present value of what will eventually go to charity, and the remaining balance passes to the charity you named at the end. It converts a single illiquid, highly appreciated position into diversified income spread over time — at the cost of giving up the principal permanently.
Who this works for — and who it doesn't
Good fit
- Owners of a single, highly appreciated, low-basis asset who want to diversify without a lump-sum tax hit
- Anyone already charitably inclined who wants an income stream in exchange for the eventual gift
- People comfortable permanently giving up the principal in exchange for deferral, income, and a deduction
Not a fit
- Anyone who might need the principal back — the contribution is irrevocable
- Smaller gains where the legal and trustee setup and administration cost outweighs the benefit
- People looking for a "have it both ways" structure that avoids actually giving to charity — that's not a CRT, and versions marketed that way draw IRS scrutiny
How it works
- You contribute the appreciated asset to an irrevocable trust before any sale is arranged — timing and sequence matter for the tax-free sale treatment.
- The trust sells the asset without paying capital gains tax at the point of sale, since it's a tax-exempt charitable trust.
- You receive a fixed (CRAT) or percentage-based (CRUT) payout for a set term or for life, which is itself taxed to you as it's received under a tiered set of rules.
- You take a partial charitable income tax deduction in the contribution year, based on the present value of the eventual charitable remainder.
- At the end of the term, whatever remains in the trust goes to the named charity.
A worked example
Elena holds $2,000,000 of stock with a $200,000 basis and wants income and diversification without a huge capital gains bill.
Elena's CRUT, illustrative
Illustrative only — actual deduction and payout figures depend on age, IRS actuarial rates in effect, payout percentage chosen, and trust term.
Common mistakes
- Pre-arranging the sale before the asset is actually inside the trust
- Choosing a payout rate too high, which shrinks the deduction and can jeopardize the trust's qualification
- Confusing a real CRT with commercial "deferred sales trust" products that skip the charitable component entirely
- Not modeling how the payout stream will actually be taxed to you as it's received
Frequently asked questions
Do I lose control of the asset once it's in the CRT?
Yes — an irrevocable CRT means the assets are legally out of your estate and controlled by the trust's terms. You retain the income stream you set up, but not the ability to reclaim the principal.
How much of my contribution is actually tax-deductible?
Only the present value of the charity's remainder interest, calculated with IRS actuarial tables based on your age, the payout rate, and the trust term — not the full value of what you contribute. A higher payout rate or longer term produces a smaller upfront deduction.
Is a CRT the same as a monetized installment sale or deferred sales trust?
No, and it should not be confused with them. A CRT requires an irrevocable gift to charity with a real, IRS-blessed structure. Deferred sales trusts and monetized installment sales are commercial products marketed as CRT alternatives that avoid the charitable requirement — and the IRS has scrutinized several of those structures heavily.
Sitting on one concentrated, highly appreciated asset?
We'll model whether a CRT actually beats a simple sale-and-diversify, and what the real numbers look like at your age and payout preference.
Book a free consultation