Home / Pitch reviews / Oil & gas deals

Oil & gas drilling deals: the deductions are real — so are the dry holes

Primary sources: IRC §263(c) (intangible drilling costs); IRC §469(c)(3) (working interest exception); IRC §613A (percentage depletion)

The honest short answer

The tax benefits in oil & gas pitches are genuine: intangible drilling costs are often largely deductible in year one, and a working interest is one of the few investments whose losses can offset W-2 income without passive-loss limits. What the slide deck underplays: the working-interest exception generally requires an ownership form that does not limit your liability — you're exposed like a general partner — and a large share of retail drilling programs lose money before tax. A deduction on a bad well is just a discount on losing.

What's legitimately true in the pitch

Intangible drilling costs (IDCs) — labor, drilling services, supplies without salvage value — are typically 60–85% of a well's cost and can be deducted when incurred.
The working interest exception: §469 expressly treats a working interest (held without limited liability) as non-passive — no REPS, no material participation hours needed.
Percentage depletion can shelter a slice of ongoing production income for qualifying small producers.

Where the pitches mislead

The liability trade is buried. The exception that makes losses deductible against your salary generally exists because you accepted unlimited liability for the well. Pitches sell the deduction and whisper the exposure.
Pre-tax economics are the product. Promoter fees, markups on drilling costs, and dry-hole risk mean many retail programs need the tax benefit just to approach break-even. Ask what the deal returns before tax; silence is an answer.
"Deduct 100% this year" glosses AMT and recapture wrinkles, excess-IDC preferences for some investors, and what happens when the program later sells.
Year-end urgency is a sales tactic. The December 28th wire "to lock in this year's deduction" is where diligence goes to die.

Questions to ask before wiring anything

What percentage of my investment goes to drilling versus fees and promotion?
Is my interest structured with unlimited liability — and am I insured for that?
What are the sponsor's last ten wells' pre-tax results?
Would this deal make sense at a 0% tax rate? If not, why does my bracket fix the geology?

Our position: for the right investor — high bracket, real risk capacity, a sponsor with an audited track record — direct energy participation can be a legitimate piece of a plan. Bought from a dinner-seminar pitch as a December tax fix, it's usually an expensive deduction.

Been pitched a drilling program?

Bring us the offering documents before you sign. We'll pull apart the fee load, the liability structure, and the actual tax math in one session — a few hundred dollars of diligence against a five-figure wire.

Book a free consultation

This review discusses a category of investment marketing generally, not any specific company or offering, and is not investment advice.